The ‘abductory twist’ during gait

The abductory twist during gait is not a condition and not a diagnosis. It is an observation during gait (specifically at the time of heel off or heel unweighting) that is reasonably common and can be due to a number of underlying entities. In an abductory twist, there is a rapid abduction of the heel, just as it comes off the ground (this is seen as a medial movement of the heel). This sometimes was called a heel whip. It is probably best to watch this video from Kevin Kirby first who explains it (and you can see the heel whip or abductory twist):

Hopefully we all on the same page and can see the abductory twist in the video, so you know what I mean when I use that term ‘abductory twist‘.

What causes an abductory twist? There are probably two distinct possibilities:
1. If the foot is overpronated beyond about midstance or around 50% of the stance phase (with a lot of variation from person to person), the foot is trying to internally rotate the tibia at the same time the opposite leg and is in the swing phase and moving forward. The swing phase leg is rotating the pelvis and leg externally. This means that the foot is trying to rotate the tibia internally and the other leg and pelvis is trying to rotate it externally, creating a conflict! In an abductory twist, it is assumed that initially the pronated foot causing the internal rotation moment wins the battle and foot does not supinate to accommodate that proximal external rotation moment that is coming from above due to the action of the other leg. As soon as some weight comes off the heel, the friction between the ground and foot can no longer resist that external rotation moment that is coming from above and all the pent up energy is released in the form of the abductory twist. There are many different causes of overpronation, but any one of them that overpronates the foot beyond that stage where the foot should be supinating is potentially going to create an abductory twist.

2. The second alternative explanation is that there is something blocking motion at the first metatarsophalangeal joint (big toe joint). As the heel starts to come off the ground that joint has to start bending so the body can progress forward over the ground and if it can’t move (for whatever reason), the body has to compensate for that block in motion. One of the ways it moves to get around that blocked joint is for the foot to roll off the medial side of the first metatarsophalangeal joint so it does not have to dorsiflex, resulting in the abductory twist at the heel. A number of different things can block motion at that joint, such as hallux rigidus (+/- osteoarthrtis), a functional hallux limitus, a high force to get the windlass mechanism established, or a shoe that is very stiff in the forefoot. Sometimes these do not actually demonstrate an abductory twist: as that metatarsophalangeal joint does not want to move, they can just lift the foot off the ground and circumduct the leg around to the side to get around the block at the joint.

What are the consequences of an adbuctory twist?
There are probably two consequences of this. One is that it is probably inefficient as the muscles are going to have to work a lot harder during gait if it is present. The other is that it is going to load different tissues differently to what they probably should be loaded and this has the potential to increase the risk for injury. The abductory twist itself is not necessarily a problem as it is a sign of another problem, that may or may not be a problem (eg overpronation; high windlass forces; hallux rigidus, etc).

How to manage an abductory twist?
Theoretically this is easy. You just make sure that the foot is not overpronated past the point when it should be supinating (to stop that you treat whatever is causing it; bearing in mind that there are multiple possible causes of this and there is no one size fits all treatments for it). You also have to make sure the first metatarsophanageal joint can easy dorsiflex under load (to encourage that you treat whatever is causing it; bearing in mind that there are multiple possible causes of this and there is no one size fits all treatments for it). In some cases (eg hallux rigidus), this is not possible and the only solution is to admit defeat and use something like a rocker sole to facilitate that sagittal place movement. The treatment is based on the caveat that its actually causing a problem and needs treating.

Does that make sense?

Last updated by .

,

6 Responses to The ‘abductory twist’ during gait

  1. billy bridle July 16, 2013 at 2:55 am #

    Thanks for the article mate in. My case , i have been told my left big toe is indeed stiff and does not bend the way it should – i also do pronate sharply just before toe off on both feet – i tend to run in shoes considered transisional. Netural runners that are flexible – pureflows, kinvaras – for my faster stuff i go more minimal.

    Is it a matter of process of elimination to see what will minmize the twist? Or would you recomend a full gait anylis

    Others issues. – Ive had piriformas issues in the past and have been recently told my spine is twisted at the pelvis

  2. billy bridle July 16, 2013 at 3:35 am #

    Ive just been thinking about this pronation on my left side with the stiff big toe – just before the toe and on the outter edge of the toe are hot spots for me!! Im guessing this is my max force toe off spot. this last second pronation my also explain why in some photos i have i appear to have bow/knocked knees…

  3. jon iriberri July 19, 2013 at 12:53 pm #

    Hi Caig: i apreciatte so much your job. In this case… could be combiation of both + metatarsal end propulsion insted of firt finger control of direction in the take off?

  4. Andrea July 29, 2013 at 2:43 pm #

    This post describes what’s been going on for me to a T. Thank you for writing it. In my case, my right big toe is blocked. I’ve been working on rolling through the big toe by focusing on it while walking/running. I started at 60% flex and am now up to 80%. My PT thinks this is the cause of my twist. Combined with that I’m dealing with posterior tibialis tendon tightness (not to the point of dysfunction) and my pelvic/hips rotate forward on the right…As you can imagine, it all goes hand in hand…

    It all started a handful of years ago with a pressure spot under my second metatarsal. I do have Morton’s toe, but the cause is more what I have described above rather than just being because my second toe is longer than the big toe.

    Anyway, thought I’d share my situation in case it helps others.

  5. John Dunham June 11, 2014 at 6:00 am #

    What an excellent explanation of what I’m experiencing. Anyone know why type of clinician I should discuss this with? Sports Medicine specialists, PT, etc? I’d like to get a gait analysis. I live in the north county San Diego area.

    Thanks in advance!

  6. Mike Haydon July 28, 2015 at 2:05 am #

    Thanks so much for this. My big toes have full range of motion, so I’ll look deeper at fixing that internal/external rotation tension. Makes so much sense and has been a problem for me for a while. It and whatever weaknesses/tightness that are causing it is limiting my ability to run the mileage I need for marathons, causing slow times when I know I can go much faster.

Leave a Reply